Find Nail Polish in NYC

Follow for updates and new posts about great places to shop.

Check out the Gotham Polish map

Update 06/17/14: I'm turning on the comments for this page. If you have an update about a store (maybe it's closed now or something) or a new store to add, leave a comment!

Introducing the Where to Shop by Brand Guide! More brands will be added.

China Glaze
Color Club
Deborah Lippmann

ABC Carpet & Home - carries Priti Polish
888 Broadway (between 18th and 19th)

American Apparel
Various - see store locator

660 Madison Ave

Beauty 35
505 8th Ave (corner of 35th St and 8th Ave)
*Please note that as of March 2012, Beauty 35 no longer carries China Glaze*

Beauty Plus Salon
2568 Broadway (between 96th and 97th)

Bed Bath & Beyond
Chelsea: 620 Sixth Ave between 18th and 19th St
TriBeca: 270 Greenwich St btw Warren & Murray St
Upper East Side: 410 East 61st Street and 1st Avenue
Queens (Bulova): 72-15 25th Avenue, East Elmhurst, NY 11370
*Please note that the Lincoln Center location does not carry nail polish

Belleza Salon
47 West 42nd St (across from Bryant Park)

1000 3rd Ave (between 59th and 60th St)
504 Broadway (Soho - between Broome and Spring St)

Union Square: 865 Broadway
Upper East Side: 1311 3rd Ave
Upper West Side: 2305 Broadway

Brighton Beauty Supply (Brooklyn)
1305 Kings Highway (between 13th and 14th)

Catbird (Brooklyn)
219 Bedford Ave

CLIO Beauty Supply (Queens)
75-17 Roosevelt Avenue

Clyde Chemist
926 Madison Ave

C.O. Bigelow
414 6th Ave (between 8th and 9th St)

Cosmetic Market
15 East 37th St (between Madison and 5th Ave)

Cosmetic Show
150 East 55th St (between Lexington and 3rd Ave)

Various - see store locator

D&D Nail Supply (Brooklyn)
5824 Fort Hamilton Pkwy
Brooklyn, NY 11219

Duane Reade
Various - see store locator

Essentials Now Closed
123 5th Ave (between 19th and 20th St)

478 3rd Ave (at 33rd St)

Essentials Plus
2259 Broadway (between 80 and 81st St)

The Face Shop
35 West 32nd St, #2 (between Broadway and 5th Ave)

Feel Beauty Supply (Brooklyn)
1592 Flatbush Ave (at 31st St) Marine Park Brooklyn, NY 11210
1023 Flatbush Avenue Brooklyn, NY 11226

Fragrance Warehouse Outlet
301 Madison Ave (between 41st and 42nd St)

Gideon's Drugs
1385 Broadway (corner of 38th St)

Harmon Face Values
675 6th Ave (between 21st St and 22nd St)

Haven Spa - they sell Zoya!
150 Mercer Street (between Prince and Houston St)

Henri Bendel
712 5th Ave (between 55th and 56th St)

Hudson Pharmacy
345 Hudson St (between King St & Charlton St)

1592 Broadway (at 48th St)
75 9th Ave, 5th Floor (between 15th and 16th St)

Irmat Pharmacy
2 Park Ave (between 32nd and 33rd)

Jaros Drugs
25 Central Park West 9 (at 63rd Street)

Joe Fresh
110 5th Ave (between 16th and 17th St)
510 5th Ave (corner of 43rd St)

Kiko Cosmetics
1 Garden State Plaza, Paramus, NJ 07652 (not in NYC, but it's close!)

Kissena Nail & Beauty Supply (Queens) *sells China Glaze
5906 Kissena Blvd
Flushing, NY 11367

Lord & Taylor
424 5th Ave (between 38th and 39th St)

MAC Cosmetics

151 West 34th St

Manhattan Beauty Supply
121 Chambers Street (between Broadway and Church St)

Metro Drugs
7 West 14th Street (between 5th and 6th Ave)

Nails Max International (Brooklyn) *Small inventory of China Glaze
6009 Fort Hamilton Parkway
Brooklyn, NY 11219

Nars Flagship Boutique
413 Bleecker St

New London Pharmacy
246 Eighth Ave

Nordstrom Rack
60 East 14th St (corner of 4th Ave; next to Best Buy)

Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics
140 Ludlow Street

Optima Beauty Supply
22 John Street

Polished Beauty Bar - get your Zoya here, girls!
250 West 78th Street (off Broadway)

281 Mott Street

Pro Health Pharmacy
370 Lexington Ave

Various - see store locator

Rite Aide
Various - see store locator

Saks Fifth Avenue
611 5th Ave (between 49th and 50th St)

Sally Beauty Supply
Brooklyn: 2129 Ralph Ave
Queens: 7417 Grand Ave #3
Staten Island: 2060 Forest Avenue, Staten Island

Various - see store locator

Sharp Rite Beauty Supply (Brooklyn) - sells Misa and $5.99 Zoya!
1682 E 13th St, #1, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Soho Pharmacy
23 6th Ave (in TriBeCa; corner of Walker St)

Solution Beauty Source
138 Fulton Street

Space NK
1000 3rd Ave (inside Bloomindales)
968 Lexington Ave (between 70th and 71st)
217 Columbus Ave (corner of 70th)

Street Fair Cosmetics
This is a traveling vendor that sells makeup and nail polish. For locations, see their Facebook page.

TJ Maxx (selection varies and is not consistently available)
Upper East Side Bridgemarket: 407 East 59th St (on 1st Ave)
Columbus Circle: 250 West 57th St (on 8th Ave)
Upper West Side: 808 Columbus Ave (at 97th St)
Chelsea: 620 6th Ave (between 18th and 19th St)
Financial District:14 Wall Street

Ulta, Rego Park Center (Queens)
61-35 Junction Blvd, Rego Park, NY

Various - see store locator

Wigs and Plus
49 West 14th St (between 5th & 6th)

Windsor Pharmacy
1419 6th Ave (corner of 58th St)

Z Chemists
40 West 57th Street (between 5th and 6th Ave)

Zitomer Pharmacy
969 Madison Ave, #1

99 Cents and Discount Depot - sells Kleancolors!
1447 Richmond Avenue
Staten Island, NY 10314

Thank you to the following ladies for sharing places to shop:

I am not affiliated with any of the stores listed nor do I receive any compensation from them.

*Updated 06/17/14

1 comment:

  1. Wow!! Amazing blog! Love This!

    Those who are looking for safe and long lasting permanent makeup in Melbourne speak to Shelley at (03) 9014 9576